Singing in St. Andrews > Comments > "Review of Singing in St. Andrews"
Piece Comment
Commenter Profile
- Eric Nuzum
- Username: ericnuzum
- Location: Washington, District of Columbia
- Joined PRX: Sep 06, 2003
Piece Information
- "Singing in St. Andrews"
- Summary: A man courts his wife in Scotland.
4 comments
5 star: |
|
(1) |
4 star: |
|
(1) |
3 star: |
|
(2) |
2 star: |
|
(0) |
1 star: |
|
(0) |
Review of Singing in St. Andrews
Eric Nuzum
Posted on October 27, 2003 at 12:20 PM
I'd like to see the narration stripped out of the interview itself. Once the narration describes the kissing and blushing, I realized a didn't need a narration anymore--I just want to hear them. Everything the internal narration says after the basic introduction (ending about :35 into piece) is either covered elsewhere or redundant to the interviewees' comments. I listened to it a few times, mentally edited out the voice over, and I think it would make the portrait even stronger. Further, I must admit that I agree--the bookends of "Amazing Grace" feel a little cliche here. Bagpipe music isn't mentioned in the piece--so why is it there?