Comments by Tripp Sommer

Comment for "Primary Sources - Have Mercy on My Soul" (deleted)

User image

Review of Primary Sources - Have Mercy on My Soul (deleted)

World War II vet and narrator Vaughn Short
shares the memories of war that still haunt him and how, all these years later, he has made efforts to reconcile what he wrote about a dead Japanese soldier and left on his grave.
The piece is sparse, just Short's voice and an intermittent flute for pause and punctutation.
The writing is clear and brings narrator and listener through the WWII experience to the present.
It's insightful and thought-provoking.
Short's writing and delivery bring us images of his experiences.

Comment for "Local News Sucks"

User image

Review of Local News Sucks

Many of us have opinions about the news on TV, but few take the time to turn them into a radio piece. Ben Hyde of KBOO makes comments about clips he plays from local TV news.
They are amusing first, then insightful.
The piece could make the same points in about half the time. This would also get to Ben's closing comments more quickly, which would make the piece more effective.

Comment for "Got gas?" (deleted)

User image

Review of Got gas? (deleted)

Darrell Harvey takes us for a fun ride in search of alternative tranportation. Along the way we learn why people make certain transportation choices. Darrell sets a good pace for the piece, covering six types of transportation in just over three and a half minutes. He skips the preachy approach and offers information and perspectives, sprinkled with a good variety of ambient sound.
He also highlights a strong element of alternative transportation - economy. He doesn't spend a dime getting around town!
Happy Earth Day Darrell.

Comment for ""Strawberry" by Paisley Rekdal" (deleted)

User image

Review of "Strawberry" by Paisley Rekdal (deleted)

While this piece is under the banner of National Poetry Month, there isn't any specific context
for me to air it. It would be value-added for Professor Rekdal to give some background about when and why she wrote it. Why she chose the words she did. Then we would have insight to
this poem on Failure.

Comment for "Poetry Combine"

User image

Review of Poetry Combine [Larry/Andrei]

It seems every month is poetry month for Andrei
Codrescu and this piece shows us why.
Poet and New Orleans citizen Codrescu takes us around town to meet local characters who just happen to be poets. This provides the listener with great enjoyment and insight into poetry
and how Codrescu approaches the craft.
Then he has students write a poem about the poets they met.
Codrescu and Larry Masset make it a fun way to learn about poets and their work as well as the
unique town of New Orleans.

Comment for "Bells From Everest"

User image

Review of Bells From Everest

Tina Antolini came across a great subject in Jeff Clapp. He's done one of those ultimate recycling acts - turning oxygen canisters from Mount Everest into bells. He's also a great narrator. Clapp is relaxed yet lively and conversational.
He didn't just think about this project, he did it!
I was puzzled how and why he coincidentaly received a guide about used canisters just before he left for Everest. I also would have liked to hear a bit more of the bells. Not a steady bed under his narrative. But as punctuation and an audio reminder of the fruits of his labors.

Comment for "A Century of Heroes: Week Five"

User image

Review of A Century of Heroes: Week Five

These 90 second pieces give us a glimpse into the heroics of otherwise ordinary people. It inspires the listeners to learn how the people profiled made a difference in helping or saving others' lives. It could happen to us. The writing is clear, with a good narrative element. I would prefer to hear related information (about the Hero Fund) only at the end. This would allow the story to be told without interruption.
In terms of airing the piece, I would need a local or timely hook. I hope the Carnegie Hero Fund contacts stations when a local hero is profiled.

Comment for "Voting Behind Bars"

User image

Review of Voting Behind Bars

"Voting Behind Bars" gives insight about people who are out of the mainstream...young people in jail.
While they are *allowed to vote, we find out why some see it as a moot point (I'm in jail, why should I care?) and others still feel connected to the outside world.
Having a young person asking the questions also
helps with the flow of the piece and probably made it easier for the young people to respond.
While this piece is pegged to last November's election, it still has value and is a good idea for other reporters to pursue.

Comment for "Fundraising Funnies I"

User image

Review of Fundraising Funnies

Way to go, WFIU! It's clear that a lot of hard work went into these Fundraising Funnies.
They should inspire listeners to pledge and inspire those of us at other public radio to produce our own pitches - as well as make good use of WFIU's.
A couple fell short for me, especially Andy Rooney and Clint Eastwood. Since those guys are alive and kicking, let's get *their voices to help us!
Many of the pieces are so far-fetched they bring a smile while others find a smooth way to get to the pitch. Overall, Fundraising Funnies should help bring in some serious cash.

Comment for "When Grown Men Cry (Coping with Depression)" (deleted)

User image

Review of When Grown Men Cry (Coping with Depression) (deleted)

As the piece starts, the intro goes too long. This keeps interested listeners from the depth and details such a show title promises. I would also leave"award-winning" out of the intro. Better to do than say. The interview with Father Burke gives the listener a sense of a person's actual descent into clinical depression. While the information is hard to listen to as the depression kicks in, it is real, first hand and very insightful. Just as I wanted to hear another voice - an expert - just such a source was introduced. Life lessons are offered and some can be applied by the listeners.
Co-hosting helps bring a sense of momentum to the show.
Music under the interview as he is recounting his experience with depression detracts from the weight of the topic.

Comment for "The Trouble With CAFTA" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Trouble With CAFTA (deleted)

I found it interesting to learn about CAFTA. It seems to live mainly in the shadow of NAFTA, but with similar goals and potential consequences.
The introduction got off to a great start with descriptions of waiting for the bus in Guatemala...but no audio...no ambient sound!
It moved the piece from produced to interview. Once past that, I was definitely drawn into the interview for the information presented.
I was confused as I tried to figure out how many roles Maryknoll played in this story.
Host. Expert. And?
Also, one question lasted the better part of 40 seconds and offered up four or five possibilities before the guest had a chance to answer.

Comment for "Monty Alexander ENCORE: On Bob Marley's 'Redemption Song'"

User image

Review of Monty Alexander ENCORE: On Bob Marley's 'Redemption Song'

I like the melding of music and narrative. The piece flows nicely and allows you to take in the essence of Marley and the insight of Alexander.
A lot is accomplished in a mere minute and a half, reinforcing the idea that content and production value rule over length for its own sake.
And the timing is double right to run the piece today (2/4/05). Bob Marley's birthday is this Sunday and February is Black History Month.

Comment for "Artist Embedded in Fire Alarm Factory"

User image

Review of Artist Embedded in Fire Alarm Factory

The first sound in this piece drew me in an puzzled me at the same time. Turned out to be a drill screwing parts of the art together, but I couldn't tell at first. So I'm now intrigued.
It took us a bit to get to Jane, the featured artist, but from then on she is the central figure and reporter Amy Jeffries, through her choice of actualities, gives Jane the role of
co-narrator.
The piece shows how the worlds of art and industry collide AND collaborate. Trial and error, problem solving.
By keeping an ambient sound bed under the whole story, Amy keeps us in the factory where it all takes place anyway. While I often tend away from all ambience all the time, it works here.
I am still trying to decipher if Amy said Jane "rolls" or "roams" through the factory, so a little better enunciation would have helped me follow the story.
The piece generates listener interest through elements of excitement and forward momentum.

Comment for "The Reindeer People"

User image

Review of The Reindeer People

"We were all once nomads." What a great opening line! It's like saying, "listen up, this is about all of us!". We are immediately transported to the world and lives of these amazing people.
The writing is clear and descriptive, the story fantastic yet grounded. The piece is nicely mixed. I loved the singing.
While I did air the story close to Christmas, this piece about old world people addressing modern problems is airable any time of the year.

Comment for "My Sentence"

User image

Review of The Sentence

"The Sentence" gives us insight from inside.
But twice I wrote "who are these people?".
I had a notion from the introductory notes, but some of their experience and perspective were lost on me because I didn't know who was speaking.
The music seemed appropriate to represent the young age of those who had been sentenced. And the fact that the same riff was repeated gave me a sense of the impending possiblity these kids would do MORE time. The sound of recidivism.

Comment for "Hilary Hahn: the 2015 Grammy Winner in her own words ... on J.S. Bach"

User image

Review of Hilary Hahn: In her own words ... on J.S. Bach

Producer David Schulman lets his subject, Hilary Hahn, do the talking - and the playing. Violinist Hahn tells of her love for the music of J.S. Bach from an early age. Her enthusiasm and insight come through very clearly. Hahn helps the process with great inflections in her voice as she talks about discovering Bach and why musicians so love to play his works.
The music effortlessly appears to illustrate a point and let the listener share the joy that is Bach.
Hilary mentions some musical techniques without going so deep that she loses us.
It's almost too short, but Hilary Hahn sings the praises of Bach and is done.
The tone and presence of delivery are a great match.

Comment for "School for Little Wanderers" (deleted)

User image

Review of School for Little Wanderers (deleted)

This piece immediately takes us into the lives and experiences of teen moms. But, mostly we hear directly from the teachers, not the mothers.
Good explanations of what personal and family circumstances leads these girls becoming teen moms - and how this class helps them with life and parenting.