Comments by Kari Chapin

Comment for "Biography of 100,000 Square Feet"

User image

Review of Biography of 100,000 Square Feet

I felt transported to this plaza via the many different prospectives I was treated to throughout this piece, from regular people who experienced the plaza in their youth, to the homeless and junkie population who live there now, to the folk who encounter the plaza on their daily commute. Hearing from the man who designed the plaza was a powerful addition to the piece. You can hear the love in his voice for this project and his disappointment in the way things turned out. Yet he wouldn’t change a thing, which I found moving. The background sounds were amazing and the music chosen matched the feeling of the piece very well. Personally, I really appreciate these in depth behind the scenes views into everyday places. Imagine how many people encounter the UN Plaza everyday and wonder what really goes on there… Listening to this with my morning coffee was 30 minutes well spent.

Comment for "Terminally Blonde"

User image

Review of Terminally Blonde

I laughed out loud. A lot. This must have taken forever, and I am so glad that the time was taken to do it. I am going to play this for my friends. It would be great if this, or something like it could be made into some kind of series. Very good.

Comment for "RN Documentary: Games Afoot"

User image

Review of RN Documentary: Games Afoot

Fun! This light-hearted piece was just what I needed on a Monday morning. I enjoyed hearing/learning about how board games are invented. This piece takes the listener to cafes in Amsterdam to conventions in Germany. The people interviewed in this piece are interesting and the visual descriptions of places where interviews take place very clear and good.
I had never given much thought to how board games came into being, and now I am motivated to learn the history of the ones I like to play the most.
A topic that might seem like a bit of a bore on the outside was presented well and was even intriguing. I learned a lot from listening to this piece. For example, designers of board games in Germany have their name on the game box. They are treated like an author would be and I found that to be very interesting. That makes the games more personal and I like the idea.
This piece would work well on a morning show or on a Sunday afternoon.

Comment for "David Byrne Does PowerPoint"

User image

Review of David Byrne Does PowerPoint

I must admit that I found this piece searching through PRX for things I like. When I found a piece on one of my favorite musicians, I had to listen.
I would like to say that while this piece is visually rich, I think the listener needs to have some knowledge about PowerPoint. I do not, and therefore did not really understand much of what was said. Clearly two sides of the PowerPoint camp are represented in this piece which I liked, but I didn’t come away learning anything new. However, the way the PowerPoint presentations are described is very good, and I could see them in my mind.
I think this piece would work well if there was a strong lead in explanation of PowerPoint and what it could mean to the listener. Also, it seems to me that the very first word we hear is cut off which makes the opening of the piece a bit harder to understand. I must add that I really enjoyed the music at the end. It is kind of spacey and had a computer-y feel to it and I thought that was neat.

Comment for "Where is the French in Lewiston" (deleted)

User image

Review of Where is the French in Lewiston (deleted)

This piece conjured up so many images for me that I had to listen to it twice. The narrator does an excellent job of painting a picture of this community, especially the 93-year old woman. I could actually see her sitting by her window sewing while listening to French jigs.
The producer did an excellent job of breaking terms down, like Franco-American, which I think makes this listener friendly no matter how much you know already know about other cultures. Yet, with her simple explanations, I never felt talked down too.
I also think there is a story within this story that could be explored further on its own. I was intrigued about the church that was turned into a Heritage Center and that the process was recorded and filmed by the youth of the town. I would love to hear more about this effort taken on by 8th graders in Lewiston.
Listeners get a sampling of many different people in the town, and I appreciate that. The producer did a great job brining in the many aspects of the history of these people and their community – without being topic-jumpy or leaving something out. I feel like I got a glimpse into another way of life, which is one of the experiences I look for when listening to Public Radio.

Comment for "Embroidery Felon"

User image

Review of Embroidery Felon

I think that this piece has a lot of potential. I wish it had been longer. It ended abruptly and I was left wanting to hear so much more. Ray Materson seems to be a lot deeper of a person with a lot more to say than what this piece let’s us hear. Some of the things I really liked about this piece were the way the voices of Ray and some mystery guy kinda overlapped. The mystery guy is gruff and said things like “…butterfly” and then you hear Ray say, so delicately, “…Monarch Butterfly” and the mystery guy says “…escaping from the cocoon” and then Ray says “…emerging from the chrysalis”. It was quite beautiful actually. I would have liked to hear more about Ray’s metamorphosis. What is he doing now? He mentions that he has made this embroidery his work now that is out of prison and I want to know more about that. Beautiful piece, just to short.

Comment for "We see it all: life through the eyes of a photo developer"

User image

Review of We see it all: life through the eyes of a photo developer

I am having a hard time really putting what I thought about this piece into words. The photo developer, who is also a photographer himself, is not someone that I really liked. I felt like this piece was sort of trying to justify who this guy is, and why he feels the way he does about processing pictures. He seemed mildly judgmental about the pictures he develops everyday and I am not sure I like that perspective. The listener is taken back to his childhood, when he was first given a camera, yet I never really felt the connection the piece was trying to make. We also get a glimpse into why he did not like his photography program in college and how that has skewed his vision and philosophy of photos in general today. But again, I didn’t make a connection. This piece was something I would continue to listen too if it was on, but I am not sure I would be happy about the time spent when it was over. I think the idea is a good one, but something about the guy who was interviewed just didn’t sit right with me.

Comment for "Parking Ticket Writer-Long Version"

User image

Review of Parking Ticket Writer-Long Version

I really liked this piece! Not just the story, but the woman telling it as well. She was honest, funny and you could tell that while she didn’t normally like the people she encountered, or rather who encountered her, that she felt she had a job to do and she does it with heart. This brief glimpse into the other side of parking tickets was fun and I am so glad I chose this piece to listen to. If I had heard it when driving into work it would have made me laugh and probably wave to any “Parking Control Aide” that I saw walking down the street. I feel that this piece was unusual and informative. Like the reviewer before me, I would want to hang out with this woman and hear more of her stories.

Comment for "Lenny Bruce Gets Busted"

User image

Review of Lenny Bruce Gets Busted

Wow. I am 30 or so years old, and all the information I had stored in my brain about Lenny Bruce was mostly gleaned from Kid Rock and REM songs. I had no idea about the struggle Lenny Bruce went through. For the most part I knew he was a junky and a comedian. I guess these days it is easy to take free speech for granted (more or less). The clips of his act that were included in this piece seem so tame compared to what I hear on my local rock station in the morning, not to mention what anyone can hear when watching the television at any time of the day. I feel like I have learned something, and that I have a lot to think about (and be thankful for) now as well. The sound in this piece was excellent and the music at the end moving, and was the perfect backdrop to the sadness I felt. It has a historical feel too it and I greatly enjoyed it.

EDIT: I could not stop thinking about Lenny Bruce all day and spent most of my working hours trying to learn more about him over the internet and checking to see what my local library had available on him.

Comment for "SubwayLand"

User image

Review of SubwayLand

I liked this piece, but it requires some kind of lead in. It does not stand alone. I think if the narrator had stated why he was in the subway looking for inspiration it would have plumped it out more, if you will. Instead he says things like “I wrote a column once…” and I think “Why?” More background would have been helpful. However, if it was included in a series about finding inspiration for creative endeavors, then I believe it would fit nicely. The sound was very good. I felt like I was in the subway, which I greatly enjoyed.

Comment for "Josh"

User image

Review of Josh

I adored this piece. Everything about it. It is compelling, touching and makes me want to write Josh and the interviewer both letters thanking them. The content is moving, the story is unique, and I gave it my attention the whole way through. If I had any critique, it would be that the interviewers voice sometimes fades, and the overlap of Josh talking once, and only once, seemed to overlap too much and the last bit of music at the end ends abruptly and was a little distracting.
Overall, outstanding.

Comment for "Holiday for Gearheads" (deleted)

User image

Review of An American in Paris, Thanksgiving 2004 (deleted)

I liked it! Could have been a little less topic-jumpy - if you know what I mean - but I learned a few facts about Paris and France that I didn't know before. The background noise was wonderful! Subway sounds too people dining. Again, it jumped too much from observation to observation for my taste. There were some really good things in this piece that I think could have been expanded upon.

Comment for "Carthedral"

User image

Review of Carthedral

I really like the topic of this piece. I love learning about the oddities that make up my own community as well as those of others. However, I felt this story was lacking. The interviewer did not do a good job of making me FEEL the car or what it was really like. Plus, the commentary often sounded too scripted, and didn't flow easily into the interviewed segments. Also, the interviewer sounded very animated at times and then very somber at times which I found distracting. I ended up focusing more on the tone of the interviewer's voice and the way she pronounced her words than on what she was saying. I could have used more background into why the owner of the car wanted her car to be this way - why she drove a hearse in the first place, and how she got the things she used to make the car unique. Where did all those dentures come from? Why is she fascinated with death? Again though, I think the story behind a 'carthedral' could be very interesting.